Feminist Standpoint Theory Revisited. Susan Hekman. I N , THE PUBLICATION of Nancy Hartsock. Sex, and Power changed the landscape of feminist theo. Feminist standpoint theory, then, makes a contribution to epistemology, within a number of disciplines—such as Dorothy Smith, Nancy Hartsock, Hilary Rose. Reviewing Hartsock: The Feminist Standpoint: Toward a Specifically Feminist Historical Materialism. Hartsock looks to answer the general.

Author: Tazahn Voodooll
Country: Ethiopia
Language: English (Spanish)
Genre: Business
Published (Last): 10 May 2012
Pages: 274
PDF File Size: 13.49 Mb
ePub File Size: 8.92 Mb
ISBN: 544-4-73023-605-6
Downloads: 29519
Price: Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]
Uploader: Kegar

On the other hand, others view this concept as problematic and stereotypical towards males as it makes all men seem like they are constantly trying to take control and that they seem like they know more than women do. There has been agreement between feminist standpoint theorists that a standpoint is not just a perspective that is occupied simply by the fact of being a woman.

Black women offer an alternative position that reveals a representation of others from a different perspective. This is due to the fact that certain realities of oppression are invisible to those who are in the dominant groups because they do not experience this oppression in the same way as the oppressed group.

The works of Mary Prince and Mary Seacole are the more commonly known writings today. Patricia Hill Collins first introduced the idea of Black feminist epistemology saying that it derives from the personal experience of Black women dealing with both racism and sexism. Feminist standpoint theories work towards an epistemic approach that continues to value objectivity albeit rethought and reworked as a goal of enquiry, while at the same time accommodating, analyzing and understanding the effects of social location on epistemic agents and on knowledge.

By portraying African-American women as self-defined, self-reliant individuals confronting race, gender, and class oppression, Afrocentric feminist thought speaks to the importance that knowledge plays in empowering oppressed people.

Standpoint feminism

Person A approaches a building and enters it unproblematically. The privileged group may be totally unaware of how their actions may affect the subordinate group.

However, reconciliation between feminist standpoint theories and those feminist theories which prioritize difference remains problematic and presents a dilemma: Marxist theory went below surface to uncover this ideology, and this must be done and worked out from the basis of a female experience LINK: A good proportion of the work that has since built on early moments in feminist standpoint theory has focused on incorporating considerations of difference within feminist standpoint theories.

Black feminist thought is grounded in black women’s historical experience with enslavement, anti-lynching movements, segregation, Civil Rights and Black Power movements, sexual politics, capitalism, and patriarchy.

Cornell University Press, Journal of Women in Culture and Society. While violence against women remains an ongoing challenge and tragedy, women have derived epistemic advantage from the conceptual resources and clearer understanding of violence that has been afforded to them within feminist standpoints. They can affect what we are capable of knowing and what we are permitted to know.

  GPC 3030D PDF

Feminisms, postcolonialities, and modernities, Raleigh: Feminist Philosophy of Science: Duke University Press, Some critics of standpoint theories have charged that their central claim of epistemic advantage amounts to a claim of automatic epistemic privilege.

Houndsmills, Basingstoke, Hampshire, UK: The formation of a standpoint requires shared experiences of oppression and of struggle against that oppression.

Feminist Standpoint Theory

Thus, as standpoints emerge, some differences will be occluded, but some significant similarities will be thrown into sharper relief. The influence of social location on epistemic content and capacity can be nartsock throughout our epistemic practices, shaping not only the way in which we understand the world, but also the way in stajdpoint it is presented to us via experience. Several theorists emphasize the epistemic advantage afforded to those forced conceptually to straddle both sides of a dichotomous social divide.

This results in partial and distorted accounts of reality, which thereby fail to hartdock up to modernistic standards of impartiality, neutrality and universality associated with a commitment to epistemic objectivity.

The concept of a standpoint employed in feminisst standpoint theories takes a narrow meaning, owed to Marxist theory, according to which a standpoint is an achieved collective identity or consciousness. She founded feminist standpoint theory, which looked at the social world from the perspectives of women in their everyday worlds and the ways in which women socially construct their worlds.

The only works of black women that are recognized previous to this time are those from the early part of the nineteenth century.

Nancy Hartsock, The Feminist Standpoint – PhilPapers

Rosemary Hennessy – – Hypatia 8 1: However, this would require an institutionalization of these arrangements that require much deeper change to the social structure than minor shifts. Jennifer Tannoch-Bland – hartsocl Hypatia 12 1: The dual perspective available to someone in this position leaves her well-placed to recognize the underlying assumptions and evaluative commitments that drive and shape the dynamics of power within the Academy, while at the same time providing her with a critical frame of reference derived from her own experience of the Academy, within which to potentially gain a better understanding of its power structures and dynamics.

Their principal claim regarding feminist standpoint theories is that certain socio-political positions occupied by women and by extension other groups who lack social and economic privilege can become sites of epistemic privilege and thus productive starting points for enquiry into questions about not only those who are socially and politically marginalized, but also those who, by dint of social and political privilege, occupy the positions of oppressors. Boys cleanly resolve this crisis, whereas girls are much more likely to retain both parents as love objects.

A feminist standpoint may be taken implicitly as the position of all women, but what account is taken of class, race, sexuality, and other markers of difference, which structure the power relations that generate oppression, the shared experience of which forms the basis of the standpoint?


Internet Yhe of Philosophy.

Standpoint feminism – Wikipedia

This theory is considered to have potentially radical consequences because of the focus on power and the fact that it challenges the idea of an “essential truth”, [9] especially the hegemonic standopint created, passed down and imposed by those in power.

Central Themes in Feminist Standpoint Theory Feminist standpoint theorists such as sociologists Dorothy Wtandpoint and Patricia Hill Collins, political philosophers Nancy Hartsock and Alison Jaggar, sociologist of science Hilary Rose, and philosopher of science Sandra Harding extended and reframed the idea of the standpoint of the proletariat to mark out the logical space for a feminist standpoint.

This demonstrates the way in which feminist standpoint theories are grounded in feminist political practice. A feminist or women’s standpoint epistemology proposes to make women’s experiences the point of departure, in addition to, and sometimes instead of men’s. From a feminist point of view, mansplaining is defined as a male explaining something to a female in an incorrect and simple hxrtsock.

For the feminist standpoint theorist, an alternative to these strategies is to attempt to remain within the contradictory contexts, and to do so critically. This way of thinking oppresses as it constrains what can be known about being an African American woman. A dual perspective such as this, then, could form the basis of a feminist standpoint which would generate challenging questions about the social and political structures that engender the reality that black women academics experience in their professional and personal tthe.

Those truths debunk myths about me, about my relationship with the world, and about my relationships with others in that world that have heretofore been taken to be true. Heyes – – Hypatia 17 2: Terry Winant – – Hypatia 2 1: Part of a series on.

Mansplaining also makes the male who is doing the explaining harhsock overconfident about the hrtsock and makes him seem condescending.

Less clear on this point. They emerge when those who are marginalized and relatively invisible from the vantage point of the epistemically privileged become conscious of their social situation with respect to socio-political power and oppression, and begin to find a voice. The charge that feminist standpoint epistemologies are committed to a politically dangerous epistemic relativism ensues from the sttandpoint that all knowledge is socially situated and that some social values enhance the process of enquiry and the tye of knowledge.

Women’s rights by country Feminists by nationality.

It is against a background of a standard such as this that it would be possible to claim, without retreat to relativism, that marginalized standpoints can offer epistemic advantage.